You know, due to the stress of OH MY GOD SOMEONES BREAKING INTO THE HOUSE AND HES GOT A GUN! Why would anyone want only one of something? Just not for me. So you think youre perfect look in the mirror clown I am not trying to get an A here I really wonder if you can shoot at all like getting rounds on the target I think I hurt your feelings again wha what wha. No external safey, DA trigger that goes bang when you pull it.. I carried a 1911 for awhile and the duty holsters made for 1911s have the retaining strap that goes across the back of slide, which also blocks the hammer from firing pin. Glock likewise provides a slimline design, which integrates features from the Gen 3 and Gen 5 Glock guns. All of that seemed a bit verbose for a blog comment, though. On Amazon, they run about $35 just sans the NRA stamped door. I think the controversy is whether or not a loaded magazine with an empty chamber constitutes an unloaded gun. There we go. Ive said it once, Ill say it again. Carrying with an empty chamber was John Waynes great advice, applicable to old, single action revolvers. Hell, Colt still makes the Single Action Army. Repeatedly doing the same thing is training, because it becomes habit. Also, had a KelTec with a pocket clip, no holster, ever, and a Glock 40 with a clip draw, and you just need the brains to have nothing else in your carry pocket, and you wont have an issue. Or tell them to carry only 5 bullets instead of six??. Best thing you can do is buy a pistol that you can safely carry loaded with one in the chamber. Do Glocks Have Safeties? [2022] - Minutemanreview.com Do u know what the 21 foot rule is? Many firearms enthusiasts and experts consider it to be the most effective and efficient way to carry a handgun for self-defense. If all you do at the range is stand there at the bench, pick up your gun, lock the slide, insert the magazine, and press the slide stop to send the slide forward, then get on target to shoot, you're not training yourself right. Amen! Do other people carry Glocks in IWB holsters with chambered rounds? Didnt say I didnt know how, just not much use for one Bad guy dies. Ask the famous Black Athlete Plaxico Burress that did that in a New York restaurant a number of years ago. There is no way to put a round in the chamber without leaving the striker cocked, and there is no safety. I have handguns that have a magazine safety I leave the mag out a 1/2 inch in the lock box and the mag cant be rammed home while in the box(like if it were dropped). I turn it into the five gun question instead. Victoria: We do all make mistakes. PS: There was a 12 yo kid recently that subdued an attacker with a common socket wrench after Dad missed 39 times with a pistol. Do you supposes THIS guy knows the six letter word for a firearms dangerous end? In war or a defensive situation, that will get you killed. Cycling against objects using your sight is slow and not easily done. The NRA store version is about $50+ for the small size. I think the Glock leg argument is kinda straying off into another argument, that could be a good idea for its own article. I had the same concerns when I first started to carry my Glock. The Best Glocks | American Firearms I worry that my flesh pushing against the soft holster will somehow depress that little trigger safety and nudge the trigger back. This makes it about five ounces lighter than another popular 9mm Luger gun, the Glock 19. Mine, of course, is in the latter, and it's held up well to a lot of shooting. The Glock trigger is too light and too short to be safe, and I understand Glocks are way far overrepresented in the annals of ND, which is very easy to understand. Never happened yet I would rather shoot myself in the leg but still be in fight than have bad guy shoot me because I didnt have a chambered round. I carry a LC9, no problem. Thank you very much. Well your odds of dying of heart disease is about a thousand times more likely than dying from a criminal attack, so, maybe something to think about. (I don't think any of us are going to try to pocket carry a 1911 or a Glock 17.) Carry without one in the pipe for a while to get used to it. You just have to get comfortable with it. Widen your horizons. You learned something. And I include all the copy cat weapons as well as they are as common as the common cold. Think about Her all you Geniuses that sing the siren song of the Utopian world of Glock. And my Ruger .357. Good on you guys for responding here. 21 foot rule gets those people every time. Dani: In the case of an inertial firing pin, nothing but a physical block on the firing pin itself will have the slightest effect. Momentum and all. in the 20th and 21st centuries, empty chamber is just retarded. Modern revolvers (Smith & Wesson, Taurus, Ruger, Kimber) have transfer bar safeties and as such theres no need to mention it. And that is the key to any methodology, simply having the proper training. Is it safe to carry a GLOCK with a round in the chamber? A safety is much easier to manipulate than a slide though. As a matter of fact in an extreme emergency you could carry the HK with no holster and in your pocket or even waist band but if you did the same thing with a Glock you would quickly blow your balls off in short order. I suggest a CZ 75 D PCR, in 9mm. It is a DAO and . The reason that the Israelis carry with an empty chamber is because Israel does not have a concept of self defense. If you cant respect the power and danger of an automobile why would you think you could be trusted with a firearm at all let alone one without a safety? I will always carry chambered because I keep my fingers where they belong and therefore don't worry about it. As I commented after the previous article, carry so that all you have to do is draw and pull the trigger. I wouldnt worry about it. The idea behind the floating firing pin is that if the firing pin is heavy enough, but made too short to actually be driven into the primer by the hammer, then when the hammer drops, the pin will be struck hard enough to give the pin enough of its own inertia to fire the round, yet then rebound to the rear. Trigger Safety. I got two strikers, finally, couple years ago, a 9mm and a 40. I hope to later, but I just moved to a state that allows it, and our first child just turned one. Well, technically, you could also just not drop them I suppose. The G44 is the ideal pistol to start or enhance your shooting experience. Bear in mind that all Glock pistols are striker fired and are have no manual safeties. CCW - Is it Better To Carry With a Round Chambered or Not? There is no doubt about it. The Top 10 Best Handguns for Carrying (Plus Two Extras, Just in Case) What I meant was: As all who have examined a REGULAR single action revolver, like a Colt SAA or the old three screw Rugers before the transfer bar, would know. Apparently the last time it worked. What an idiot libtard if you have a gun you get good at handling it stay with your BB gun, Mad says, What an idiot libtard if you have a gun you get good at handling it stay with your BB gun. I dont condemn those who carry a striker with one in the chamber. . Your family is worth it. Even my beloved Browning High Powers (all 6 f them) gave me fits until I found some expanding ammo that would work reliably in them. The fact remains, we are always training. I agree about the Colt SAA. I have a CCW and am carrying the Glock in a Galco Stow-n-Go IWB holster. It is a compact pistol that is chambered in 9mm and is designed for concealed carry. Or a DA/SA auto. Hes squirmy and all over the place. So yes, its completely safe. All except for that one guy above who thinks muscle memory means hell never make a mistake, ever. I still counted 16, but when he starts fanning it gets a little hard to keep track. He has earned black belts in four martial arts and is a certified Krav Maga instructor. The most obvious one is we have an external safety. All terrific replies. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. If you try to have a healthy debate its always 100% of the time NOTHING but internet people telling other internet people that their particular opinion is wrong. Not a bad plan. Back in the old days of guns, they didnt really have any safety at all. Boy, that must be realllll nice. Just the same as the guy thumbing the safety off, he will beat me. Big thing, its hammer fired and its also DA/SA, so I have no problem with chambering a round and lowering the hammer. Unfortunately, some may not and I have no idea which do and which do not. Most 1911s come with a half cock safety, but again, you would have to ensure it was engaged properly and its prone to breakage. Do Glocks Have A Safety? By: Joseph Kocik | Global Ordnance News Thats intentional. These arent exactly the most concealable guns out there. I could give you many other identical examples of Glocks going off while the owner wore them or handled them. FNS9-C. You have to train how you'll fight and fight how you train. Whats the controversy? Or ya know, apply the tried by 12 or carried by 6 rule. Place your loaded, chambered G19 into the holster (not attached to your belt). I have trained chambering on the draw and while it is less effective I am still way ahead of the guy who doesnt carry. Height: 5.4. Youll probably die trying to get your semi-auto back into battery after attempting a contact shot anyway. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Note, the sentry safe does have a security vulerablity that can be mitigated by covering a hole with stainless steel tape. The round wouldnt even need to be in a chamber at all. Carrying any weapon with nothing in the chamber is carrying an unloaded weapon. At least the DA/SA or DAO provide a long hard trigger pull. One common question among Glock owners is whether or not they can shoot aluminum cased ammunition in their . While the bad guy is picking up the decoy gun and trying to shoot you with it, you draw your real piece with a round loaded. Thats all Colt added to the series 80, the internal firing pin block. In a prima facie, on-paper, in-theory sense, thats true. Best Glocks: Across Calibers & Sizes [Ultimate Guide] (Take that, NYPD!) Thats when I started looking for a better way. Sometimes I ask a question. The Glock Gen 4 and Gen 5 models have actually ended up being popular with civilians and self-defense shooters alike. He grew up hunting, fishing, and trapping. 2. I really would like to know if theres a response to my comments. This pistol gained [] It made me feel extremely uncomfortable. An empty chamber is worthless when you need it and fractions of a second count. The idea is that a gun with cartridges in it but not having one in the chamber is close to being loaded and is therefore better than a completely unloaded gun. The Glock Model 48 slimline 9mm is a state-of-the-art fighting pistol with a small grip frame any cop can master. I was shown( Thank You RES), yank that sucker out, moveaim, fire. And make sure when you holster or unholster that the holster is clear of obstructions. I appendix carry my 42 chambered, the holster covers the trigger so I feel safe carrying this way, I been carrying this way for a while without issue. Thanks for the tip. In non service activities, all occurred either nearly cheek to cheek, face to face, or less than 3 ft. when chit went south, and it happens so fast, Id bet few if any pro operators could rack then stack em I made a folder called TTAG comments, and put all pages Ive commented on in there. I have no problem carrying chambered but around the house or at the park I do not. Do you, punk? So in 2019, are you telling a revolver carrier to carry only 4 bullets instead of five?? the department said it was the pistols fault. Glocks have a feature that prevents the trigger from accidentally being pulled, blocks the firing pin until the trigger is fully pressed, and the pistol is not actually cocked until the trigger is puled. In fact, it uses S&W Shield Plus magazines. The New York Trigger as it became known had an 8-pound trigger pull. I think they heard how bad its getting over here and want to provide a better place to be, so that TTAG will be left with nothing but trolls and snowflakes. Each new design enhanced the pistol and its features. However, that may be the reason I carry a revolver, but the reason I carry a gun (as I said) is because ITS MY GODDAMN RIGHT. The G44 was thoroughly tested with a wide variety of ammunition to ensure maximum performance and . Pray the opponent was just carrying a Taser and not a knife. i carry mostly to counter the mass shooting incident the type of which where afterward everybody says if there had only been a good guy with a gun and i will more likely than not have time to draw the weapon and charge it while i get my ooda loop going. Each brand-new model enhanced the pistol and its functions. So when do you get to be a klutz if youve taken the time to train those reactions until as the experts say you not only get it right, you cant get it wrong? Passive safeties Are Not A Replacement for an active safety. Hell, try it with a taser. I carry a 5 shot .357 magnum revolver a good deal of the time. Heres a news flash, ever since Adam and Eve ate the serpents apple were all fallible. We keep our mouths shut, myob, and avoid praising glocks. He also runs his own Gun Blog and YouTube Channel. A loaded Glock is a little more dangerous than a striker with a heavier trigger and when you carry a missile behind the hammer and like a lite trigger , like I do , I advise people to carry a thumb safety , like I do . Somewhat different than in rural MS tho, speaking as one who attended a full auto shoot at a local range about a month ago. When the term "loaded" means a round in the chamber and you need to carry, either open carry or concealed, with an unloaded gun, training to be faster with your draw will be very important. And yes, I have done trigger work on 2 of my 3 Glocks. The gun is DA/SA, so the first shot is a long pull on the trigger, but I routinely practice it, so Im OK with it. The name's Jordan, but friends call me Jordy. Which gun would you choose if you could only have ONE each of: Rimfire rifle, rimfire pistol, centerfire rifle, centerfire pistol, and shotgun? It is completely safe if you take the proper precautions. So anybody can mess with anybody here at any time, by pretending to be somebody else. What is wrong with such ones is that they get a nice, warm, mushy, feeling of superiority over others by putting them down. P.T. This means that if the hammer is carried down on a live round, the firing pin will still not be able to touch the primer, even though the hammer is sitting right down on the pin. Have you ever failed to yield the right of way when making a left turn? The Glock 43 is VERY close in size to the Glock 42, but chambered for that 9mm cartridge some people demand - or at least don't frown on like they do the .380ACP. For myself I carry an HK P30sk with the double action hammer in the down position and the manual safety on. They have defense of the State, of their comrades, or of other citizens.. The Glock 17 is a full-size pistol that is chambered in 9mm. Kentucky CCDW Instructor. Does the Mossad or other Israeli special services Israeli carry? Theyre both safe and useful within their own parameters, and people are free to choose the one they prefer. If anybody could advise me, I'd be grateful. Glock handguns are extremely personalized, and gun owners have the choice to change out sights and sets off. Itll never come out to get cleaned, the retention will never fail, the gun will never fall out when you unbelt to take a crap in other words you dont make mistakes. Mr Hoober, If you werent too busy arrogantly doubling down, you might consider trying it some time instead of pretending you know everything but I suppose you are probably more interested in getting audience engagement than giving good advice. Are Glocks Safe To Carry Chambered. you roll the dice. Glock G21 439. at Guns.com. See? Ever have your computer go slow for a second, but then it opens two(or more) of whatever you clicked on? Which gets me to this. 1:43:08-1:43:32. so i compensate for that with situational awareness and trying not to put myself in situations or places where that will happen The IDF has quit carrying with a round chambered. Is A Glock Safe To Carry Chambered. Glocks have a trigger pull of 5-1/2 to 6 pounds. However, that also creates issues. Unlikely. 1; 2; Next. Revolvers with their heavy double action trigger pulls are perfectly safe to carry with a round in the . But it used to work fine, a year or so before that. sounds like bullshat urban legend.. One observation concerning all the keyboard commandos here they seem to make the assumption that people primarily carry guns in preparation for a gunfight, and this is not always true. The end result is the same, but the means to that end are directly opposite in how they function. I once had a grim laugh when one Jethro Bodine (after emerging from his out house) told me he bought a Glock because he could not stand the worry of carrying his 1911 cocked and locked. I once owned 12 of them. Is A Glock Safe To Carry Chambered - Todd Lyons Firearm experts, including myself, consider the design completely safe and dependable. This is not remotely comparable to carrying a semiauto with an empty chamber, where the slide must be racked to make the gun ready to fire. Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. It wont matter if the slide is in battery or not. In a SA revolver, the next round is instantly available anyway, whether fully loaded or one short, quicker out of the leather for the first, second, and third shot than any other existing action type. Glock and carrying with chambered round | Page 2 | SIG Talk Absolutely YES!! I hope r.i.p is on your tombstone if you fail in a confrontation. The Glock Gen 4 and Gen 5 models have become very popular with civilians and self-defense shooters alike. A S&W Model 329. Glock 22 Gen 3 (Photo: Gunprime) The full-size Glock 22 was made to fill the gap between .45 and 9mm. I assume it had something to do with its mechanics. It is also the choice of many Canadian cops services. Options are good. So Move. Do other people carry Glocks in IWB holsters with chambered rounds? Is it safe to carry a Glock with a round in the chamber? - Quora Being a klutz is one thing. 8 Modern Pocket Carry Pistols for under $600 | OutdoorHub Its your right to be retarded. Ugggghhhhhh why are we still talking about this? If I have to carry a compact, its a DA only with no safety or one with the safety off. With only six on tap anyway, whats one less? YouTube it. The engineer who designed a take down system whereby the slide has to be forward and you have to pull the trigger must have on that day tripped out on LSD. I answered the asked question. The reason was that there wasnt anything between the hammer and either the nipple or the primer of the cartridge. The hammer connects with a firing pin thats integrated into the frame, which strikes the primer. The gun itself Cannot be rendered safe without the chamber being empty. COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. Does anyone ride the hammer down on their gun with a LIVE ROUND in the chamber? Just the easier reloading of the old Ruger 3 screw models (or any other regular types like the Colt SAA) vs the new ones, makes up for that one extra round, at least IMO. His response could be ro shoot you with your gun. The general answer is most certainly yes however there are a few considerations. This subject is DOA just like the OP. Let the one with no traffic tickets throw the first stone. So you have no quibble with the line; If dropped, the hammer could contact the primer and therefore, fire., in relation to SA revolvers? As for kids, had 3 daughters, all knew all weapons were loaded, all were shooting bb guns by 5, learned safety and marksmanship, and by ten, the oldest could out shoot me with the Smith 9mm semi, steel. As I mentioned elsewhere here, the trigger pull and safety mechanism are irrelevant to the *proximate* cause of any Glock discharge Im aware of. In the case of a fast draw in a conflict, you dont have time to check, but you still have time to keep your finger out of the trigger guard. You rotate the cylinder halfway between the nipples and lower the hammer on the carry notch. On paper? WOW! And my Glock 17. With hammer fired guns, we have more options to prevent guns from accidently firing. A 1911 or single-action pistol in Condition 1 is comparable to a striker-fired, safe-action pistol, like a Glock, which is always in a semi-cocked condition when a round is in the chamber anyway. Just bookmark the page you commented on, and then check back once in a while. This also means that if the firing pin somehow gets enough inertia to hit the primer, from some other source than the hammer (whatever that source might be), and then the round in front of the pin suddenly ceases motion, the firing pin will continue forward into the round anyway, no matter what the hammer, trigger, barrel, or etc, do. Now that we know what it means to have one in the chamber, let's figure out whether it is safe to carry a "loaded gun" with you. Is it just something one has to get used to? OK , Ill bite this time , I let it pass the first (hundredth) time , but Im all in now . I like having a gun ready to shoot but I need a second chance when Im juggling. And you should be, too. Farago sells out, the site gets taken over by snowflakes who spend every minute lining up sponsored content, and the content section gets taken over by trolls and vlads. How often are you drinking a glass of milk, or spilling coffee, or having a horn tooted at you while actually handling or holstering your firearm? Because it has no external safety that means you are only 5 lbs away from making the gun fire. Also thank goodness I dont even have to make THAT choice. I didnt mention this stuff because in the original post because the number of people out there who keep a single-action revolver as a home defense or self-defense gun is likely negligible. Try it with any style sidearm. Can You Shoot Aluminum Cased Ammunition In A Glock? Understanding The Good username though. The full magazine has ten rounds, and the "+1" is the round that is in the chamber. Of course theres a difference between driving and shooting. Ive done this quite a bit when rabbit hunting. I actually think thats worth a healthy debate and article all on its own. When she holstered her Glock .40 it went off and the bullet went down her leg utterly destroying it. Seems more in line with your abilities. Use whatever gun you want. Carry it in your home in the holster you're going to use in public, without a round in the chamber, but with the striker in the ready position or "cocked" and see if you have an issue with the trigger being pulled. Situational risk assessment. But its hard to imagine a situation where a dropped gun firing into the ground could be a danger. Here's my situation: Carrying the pistol with a round in the chamber freaks me out. I have no problem with a 1911 locked and loaded, there has been one in my car since I bought it in 2010. My G19 pull is about 4-1/2# about the same as a lot of 1911 guns. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p28yT3Z3oj8&t=7347s However, with an unchambered semi-auto, that may be a more credible concern. Unchambered carry is a bad idea because: It comes down to your comfort, training and repetitive use. What kind of a moron thought THAT was a good idea? I have four (4) SA revolvers. By all means, carry what you are competent to handle effectively and safely. Not the first time I have seen you feed the gun grabbers agenda either. I have these 2 hidden and had mounted in my house. Time waits for no man, and neither do bad guys. You may need your weak side arm to hold an attacker at bay while you draw, etc. It will catch on and you will be a rock star! Amen brother. If my chamber is empty, I obviously increase the chances that my gun wont be useful when needed, but I also reduce the chance of a ND caused by a minor in my care. Israeli Carry? - Creedmoor Training Academy, LLC. Width: 1.18. Literally has nothing to do with firearm safety. But thats good. Is A Glock Safe To Carry Chambered. Sad, isnt it? Mike Cumpston [Public domain], via Wikimedia CommonsCredit where due, its true that in days long past the best practice was to carry your revolver with the hammer resting on an empty chamber or on an empty primer nipple in pre-cartridge pistols.